Employers
Disciplinary hearing checklist for employers
A dismissal or sanction is fair only if there is both a fair reason and a fair procedure. Use this checklist to prepare for, conduct and conclude a disciplinary hearing, working through the stages below in order.
Before the hearing
- Investigate first: statements, documents, footage. Date your notes.
- Suspension: suspend an employee before the hearing only if there is a fair reason, such as a reasonable belief that they committed serious misconduct and that their presence could interfere with the investigation or witnesses. The suspension must be precautionary, not punitive. Keep it on full pay until the disciplinary proceedings are concluded, keep it as short as possible, and confirm it in writing.
- Appoint a chair who was not involved in the incident or the investigation.
- Draft each charge in plain words: what happened, when, where, and the rule or standard broken.
- Serve a written notice, in a form and language the employee can understand, that sets out the charges, the date, time and venue of the hearing, and the employee’s rights (listed below).
- Allow the employee reasonable time to prepare.
Rights to state in the notice
- Assistance by a fellow employee or a trade union representative
- An interpreter, if needed
- To state their case, call witnesses and question the employer’s witnesses
At the hearing
- Keep minutes or a recording.
- Open by explaining the charges and the procedure. Let the employer present its evidence, then give the employee a full opportunity to respond, call witnesses and question the employer’s witnesses.
- Decide on the evidence, on a balance of probabilities. Ask four questions: did the employee break a rule; was the rule valid and reasonable; did the employee know, or could they reasonably be expected to know, of the rule; and has the employer applied the rule consistently?
- Hear mitigation before deciding the sanction: length of service, previous warnings, the circumstances.
After the hearing
- Choose a sanction that is proportionate to the seriousness of the misconduct, taking the mitigation into account, and consistent with how similar cases have been treated.
- Give the outcome in writing, with reasons.
- If the outcome is dismissal, inform the employee in writing of their right to refer the dispute to the CCMA or the relevant bargaining council within 30 days of the date of dismissal.
This guide is general information and not legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts, so obtain legal advice before taking disciplinary action.
Reference: Code of Good Practice: Dismissal.
General information, not advice on your matter. For advice, book a consultation.
